Search the Archives           Subscribe           About this News Service           Reader Comments

Archived updates for Tuesday, August 30, 2005

Design Inventorship Contributions Must Be Substantial

In Sunbeam Products, Inc. v. Wing Shing Products (BVI) LTD. (Fed. Cir., August 24, 2005; nonprecedential) the court affirmed that changes suggested by Sunbeam's Mr. Coffee employees were not sufficient to rise to the level of joint inventorship for the Wing Shing coffeemaker claimed in Design Patent No. 348,585 (right).

Between August 1991 and early 1992, employees of Mr. Coffee had a series of communications with representatives of Wing Shing regarding the coffeemaker design. In the course of those communications, Mr. Coffee employees asked that the design be changed by (1) eliminating grooves on the brew basket; (2) eliminating ridges on the reservoir cover; (3) moving the power switch from the base to the left column; (4) opening the brew basket from the left to right; (5) moving the water-level gauge from the right column to the left column; (6) inserting a metal plate on the bottom of the base; and (7) adding a shroud around the power switch. Wing Shing incorporated those changes into the design, which became known as the "AD10" model design.

The court concluded that the changes suggested by Mr. Coffee were no more significant than those made by the party claiming inventorship in Hoop:
Sunbeam argues that the district court applied the wrong test when it ruled
that the "improved design must contain an inventive concept." We disagree. In
Hoop v. Hoop, 279 F.3d 1004, 1007 (Fed. Cir. 2004), we stated that "minor
differences between the prior art and the new claim will not suffice" to make
the person who suggested the changes that resulted in the differences an
inventor. We added that the differences "must be substantial and not just superficial; the new design must contain an inventive concept." Id. (citations omitted). In particular, as a result of the changes to the design of an eagle-shaped motorcycle fairing guard made by the party claiming inventorship, the new fairing design had a noticeably different visual appearance. "must be substantial and not just superficial; the new design must contain an inventive concept." Id. The district court therefore
did not err by employing the "inventive concept" test. Furthermore, the bankruptcy court found that the Mr. Coffee employees’ contributions were not significant, considering the overall appearance of the coffeemaker as well as the limited and mainly functional nature of the suggested changes. In Hoop, we also articulated the ultimate test for design patent inventorship to be "whether the second asserted invention is ‘substantially similar’ to the first." In that case, we agreed with the trial court that the party claiming inventorship was likely not an inventor because the new fairing design had "strong similarities" to the drawings provided to that party by the inventor. Id. at 1008. In the present case, the changes suggested by Mr. Coffee are no more significant than those made by the party claiming inventorship in Hoop. Accordingly, we affirm the bankruptcy court’s ruling that Mr. Coffee was not a joint inventor of the ’585 patent.
    (22)comment(s)     translate     More Updates     Send    


Anonymous Baju Kantor Wanita Modis Terbaru 2015 said...

Thanks for taking the time to talk about this, I feel strongly about it and I benefit from learning about this topic. Please, as you gain facts, please add to this blog with new information. I have found it extremely useful

March 25, 2015 1:25 AM  
Anonymous Anti Rayap said...

parfum | Marine Contractor |
Atap Fiberglass | Cotton Bud

May 20, 2015 2:27 AM  
Anonymous Parfum said...

Anna Sui Dolly Girl Women
Carolina Herrera 212 Sexy Women
Davidoff Champion Man
Burberry London Women
Bvlgari Aqva Man
Bvlgari Rose Women
Kenzo Flower Women
J-lo Still Women

January 30, 2016 12:05 PM  
Anonymous juna said...

Resep Masakan Sederhana
Resep Brownies kukus
Resep sayur asem
Resep kuah bakso
Resep soto betawi
Resep Jus Tomat
Resep kue bolu kukus lapis
Resep donat labu kuning
Resep donat tanpa telur
Resep donat mini
Resep daging sapi
Resep Nasi Kuning
Resep Tahu Ranjau
Resep Pempek Dos
Resep bakso sapi
Resep ikan bakar
Resep martabak manis mini
Resep durian goreng
Resep donat praktis
Resep mie goreng
Resep telur pindang kecap
Resep semur telur kentang
Resep sayur asem betawi
Resep risoles isi sayuran
Resep sayur lodeh
Resep donat dunkin
Resep kue lapis tepung beras
Resep kolak kacang hijau ubi
Resep ayam bakar
Resep martabak manis bogasari
Resep Nugget ikan tuna tenggiri
Resep Nasi goreng seafood

February 18, 2016 6:59 AM  
Anonymous resep masakan sederhana said...

Resep siomay bandung
Resep Nugget sayur
Resep perkedel jagung
Resep Kue nastar
Resep martabak manis bandung
Resep capcay kuah
Resep kue kastengel
Resep rendang padang
Resep donat kentang
Resep kue kering coklat
Resep soto ayam
Resep kue macaroon
Resep semur daging kentang
Resep Kolak pisang
Resep kue nastar
Resep tongseng kambing
Resep bubur kacang hijau madura
Resep ayam goreng mentega
Resep Brownies kukus
Resep ayam bakar
Resep capcay goreng
Resep sop ayam
Resep rempeyek kacang kedelai
Resep cah kangkung
Resep perkedel kentang

February 18, 2016 8:15 AM  
Anonymous anti rayap said...

Keren artikelnya. Terus posting ya.

May 03, 2016 6:08 AM  
Blogger Zheng junxai5 said...

nike free 5.0
michael kors outlet
cheap ray ban sunglasses
air jordan femme
christian louboutin outlet
vans outlet
replica rolex watches
hollister clothing
coach outlet
tory burch outlet online
christian louboutin sale
juicy couture
coach outlet
air jordan shoes
oakley canada
michael kors handbags
michael kors outlet clearance
michael kors handbags
rolex watches
toms outlet
coach outlet store online clearances
michael kors handbags
coach outlet online
ladies cartier watches
nike trainers sale
coach factory outlet online
copy watches
discount jordans
christian louboutin shoes
coach factory outlet
coach factory outlet
oakley outlet
louis vuitton outlet online
louis vuitton handbags
red bottom shoes
michael kors outlet
kate spade outlet
louis vuitton purses
nfl jerseys

June 12, 2016 10:31 PM  
Anonymous Kondominium said...

Very insightful post. Keep up the good works. Thanks.

October 24, 2016 2:41 AM  
Blogger raybanoutlet001 said...

nike shoes
nike huarache
ugg outlet
yeezy shoes
coach outlet
cheap jordan shoes
michael kors handbags
hermes belts
rolex watches
bears jerseys

July 08, 2017 2:44 AM  
Blogger happy 123 said...

coach outlet
nike huarache
longchamp handbags
ralph lauren
nike factory outlet
oakley sunglasses
ferragamo outlet
ugg boots
fitflops sale
jordan shoes

August 02, 2017 1:33 AM  
Blogger 郑佳颖 said...

yeezy shoes
nike air max 2016
christian louboutin shoes
michael kors outlet store
lacoste outlet
basketball shoes
kobe basketball shoes
kyrie irving shoes
timberland shoes

September 23, 2017 3:05 AM  
Blogger adidas nmd said...

cheap nfl jerseys
cheap nhl jerseys
air huarache
air max 90
basketball shoes
nike blazer
nike outlet store
nike outlet store
cheap nike shoes
nike factory store

November 15, 2017 3:08 AM  
Blogger qqqqqq said...

air force 1
hermes birkin
vibram five fingers
hermes belts
supreme hoodie
nike basketball shoes
michael kors outlet store
nfl jerseys
kobe basketball shoes
true religion jeans

January 23, 2018 3:11 AM  
Anonymous Obat Ampuh Tukak Lambung said...

Article very interisting, thanks for sharing information

Pengobatan Gagal Ginjal
Obat Diabetes Melitus Alami
Pengobatan Luka Gangren Tanpa Amputasi
Obat Gabagen Sampai Sembuh
Obat Ampuh Atasi Rematik
Pengobatan Ampuh Atasi Cacingan

April 03, 2018 2:15 AM  
Blogger Fghkfhk Dfgaert said...

cheap ray bans
coach outlet
christian louboutin uk
michael kors outlet
houston texans jerseys
texans jerseys
jordan shoes
cheap nike shoes
cheap jordan shoes
saints jerseys

April 09, 2018 3:48 AM  
Blogger Yaro Gabriel said...

canada goose parka
jordan 32
kappa clothing
thunder jerseys
denver broncos jerseys
ray ban sunglasses
coach outlet
ugg boots
michael kors
adidas nmd

May 31, 2018 10:56 PM  
Blogger Yaro Gabriel said...

nike pegasus
nike shoes
michael kors outlet
dansko shoes
coach outlet online
longchamp solde
ugg boots
adidas outlet
cavaliers jerseys
cheap jordans

July 12, 2018 5:40 AM  
Blogger Yaro Gabriel said...

0730jejeVous pouvez nike femme noir et blanc trouver un grand nombre de semble être ce que vous nike air max 1 sneaker femme pourriez réaliser pour être une mariée, avec le look air jordan 11 georgetown price de cérémonie de mariage blanc typique, dans la asics gel lyte iii france dynamique mariée Bollywood, ou même obtenir une new balance chaussure de course robe à thème. En 1865, Stetson s'installa à Philadelphie, nike dynamo free canada où il projeta de produire en masse nike roshe run noir et blanc pas cher le chapeau qu'il s'était façonné même s'il voyageait en Occident.

July 30, 2018 2:06 AM  
Blogger Xu千禧 said...

mbt shoes outlet
kate spade outlet online
prada shoes
nike blazer pas cher
golden goose
michael kors outlet clearance
fitflops sale clearance
true religion outlet store
ugg boots clearance
true religion outlet

August 09, 2018 4:37 AM  
Blogger miki said...

0814jejeMieux vaut acheter une basket nike dunk femme bonne qualité une fois, et laisser les problèmes aux autres. Nous connaissons tous nike femme noir et rose beaucoup de gens "en forme" qui ne sont toujours pas satisfaits asics gel lyte v jaune de leur corps, alors commencez à être heureux maintenant avec chaussures nike pas cher fille ce que vous avez simplement parce que vous pouvez trouver asics chaussures de running gel attract femme quelqu'un qui vous a vu qui échangerait des places avec asics gel lyte v speckle femme vous à l'intérieur d'une minute. Il a servi à maintenir nike chaussures auto la?antes la pluie dehors et il pourrait également être un ventilateur pour ces jours chauds. chaussures nike homme blanche

August 14, 2018 1:41 AM  
Blogger Yaro Gabriel said...


ralph lauren uk
prada outlet
coach outlet
vibram fivefingers shoes
pandora jewelry outlet
mbt shoes
coach factory outlet
mlb jerseys
adidas outlet online
off-white clothing

September 02, 2018 11:05 PM  
Blogger zzyytt said...

nike react flyknit
puma fenty
yeezy shoes
nike air max 2019
jordan shoes
coach factory outlet
kevin durant shoes
nike shox for women
lebron shoes

October 29, 2018 3:20 AM  

Post a Comment

<< Home